WholeLottaN's
All the News that's Fit to Share
Friday, July 31, 2015
Stairs! Ha! A Staircase! We have stairs! (Still)
Part I
http://iapet.us/nicole/2005/07/stairs-ha-staircase-we-have-stairs.shtml
Part II
Ten years ago this week Mikko and I purchased our first home. A happy little house on a happy little street. Our starter home, the place we knew we'd start hosting friends, start having dogs, start a family, start living our intended dream. All these things we did! Ronnie arrived in October, Fiona arrived the following August, and Phoebe as scheduled.
Our little house of dreams was ready for all our lofty improvements. So much fun customizing and making it ours. Siding, paint, whole new kitchen. We were able to do so much to create the space we wanted. (Okay, I envisioned and Mikko supported. I won't go into the gory details of the Great Siding Color Conflict of 2005.)
But we never intended to stay. It was our starter home. It was a place to sow the seeds (hee hee) but then transfer once all was well under way. We never considered staying ten years. Seven had been the magic number. Turns out that 2013 had other things come to pass.
I have never been one to plan out my life. The whole Where Do You See Yourself in 5, 10, 15 years was really a mystery to me. And I have an imagination! You want me to see myself fighting dragon, I can do it. But my real life future path? Meh, I kinda just like to take in the journey while I walk it.
This milestone that I'm facing without my person who started it with me...this is hard. That our plan to grow out of our little house is gone. I never envisioned the next step, but I'd never fathomed that it would be this reality. I'm not sad that that plan didn't go as expected. Because I do love our home, it has grown our children, and it has offered such comfort. I'm just a little frustrated at not realizing the expectation.
This happy little house is still on a happy and thriving little street. I say that I'll never leave. Not because of some deep or slightly crazy attachment to this physical place, but because I just don't see a possible plan of how that will happen. Besides, have you seen the new Executive Powder Room? Yet...who knows what choices lay ahead on this wild, winding path? I'm sure there are plenty of fierce and monstrous dragons to tame.
--The picture is the first photo of the HQ. You can just barely see a sliver of the For Sale sign. You will also notice that you cannot see the disaster of a garage that nearly had us pass over the cutest 1947 bungalow you'd ever laid eyes on.
Thursday, May 9, 2013
It's my dream. Strong, happy, confident kids.
Item number 647 for the Parenting File:
When Emp #1 & #2 get shunned from the lunch table (and it will because little girls are bitches), the priority is helping the girls to see all the possibilities that are now open to them, not mourn the loss of one.
She can be free to:
-Experiance the awesomeness of meditative alone time.
-Search out other shunned subjects (and that will happen because little girls are bitches).
-Work on her "Making new friends" skills.
-Get in touch with old friends.
-Write (one of the CEO's favorite things to pass the time).
Every single one of those items listed above will be an essential part of moving along her life path as a successful adult. Every single one of those will make her a better person, with remarkable strength, envied character, and clear self insight.
What will not help her one bit when she reaches adulthood? Allowing those little bitches to dent her confidence or cowering to their maniacal whims. I know that when they come home in tears, wallowing in the pain of being banned, that it will be difficult to convince my girls to at least give the possibilities a try. I'm still not sure I believe the same advice my mom gave me. But I did follow that advice (mostly) and well, I'm sure I've got two out of three "better person" qualities.
I also know that it will be extremely hard for me not to march down to the school/call and rage at those little bitches parents/ream the teacher into oblivion. But I won't (okay maybe two of three). Reacting that way does not exemplify the better person that I've become by recognizing and embracing the new possibilities open to me.
When Emp #1 & #2 get shunned from the lunch table (and it will because little girls are bitches), the priority is helping the girls to see all the possibilities that are now open to them, not mourn the loss of one.
She can be free to:
-Experiance the awesomeness of meditative alone time.
-Search out other shunned subjects (and that will happen because little girls are bitches).
-Work on her "Making new friends" skills.
-Get in touch with old friends.
-Write (one of the CEO's favorite things to pass the time).
Every single one of those items listed above will be an essential part of moving along her life path as a successful adult. Every single one of those will make her a better person, with remarkable strength, envied character, and clear self insight.
What will not help her one bit when she reaches adulthood? Allowing those little bitches to dent her confidence or cowering to their maniacal whims. I know that when they come home in tears, wallowing in the pain of being banned, that it will be difficult to convince my girls to at least give the possibilities a try. I'm still not sure I believe the same advice my mom gave me. But I did follow that advice (mostly) and well, I'm sure I've got two out of three "better person" qualities.
I also know that it will be extremely hard for me not to march down to the school/call and rage at those little bitches parents/ream the teacher into oblivion. But I won't (okay maybe two of three). Reacting that way does not exemplify the better person that I've become by recognizing and embracing the new possibilities open to me.
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Next time there's a ball, ask me before someone else does, and not as a last resort!
I should know better then try to commit to doing something during the
month of September. It's always been a hectic month, will always be a
hectic month, and for whatever reason September has always always been
very difficult for me.
Book IV - Goblet of Fire
I recently read a interview piece with JK Rowling. She admitted that there were times when she wished she could go back and make some edits to her books. I believe that she was specifically talking about book 4. But book 5 and 6 and some of 7 could be applicable. But I can see why it might have been so difficult to do when the later books in the series were first written. The publisher wanted books, I believe the movies were on their way and well, there was a lot of material that needed to be covered so that the entire story played out.
With any other writer, having to read over 800 pages of their words would be daunting and be way more then any reader needed to read. With JKR, it's not the case. She writes so well, and includes so much specific detail relevant to the greater story that you rarely feel that tugging feeling of boredom. She may have needed to edit, but she sure as heck didn't waste a word on the page.
However, I feel that she could have adjusted a lot of what she did write. Cutting something here, adding more there. I think it's important that she included times of reflection. And Harry does a lot of inner discussion to really give you a sense of what he's thinking and feeling. It's repetitive. Which, given the age and attitude of Harry is very consistant. But wouldn't have those words been best served by talking more about how the 3 schools interacted with each other? Yes? But then again, maybe that is not this book?
I am a reader torn between two minds.
First and foremost I would have liked to have had more going on with the students of Hogwarts, Beauxbatons, and Durmstrang. Even when I read book 4 the first time I felt that these students came all this way, to spend a whole school year in Scotland, and all they had was THREE challenges and a dance? Well that seems like a utter and complete waste of time.
One of the very well honed skills of JKR is to write from Harry's perspective and stay there. Anything that happens, is described solely through Harry's involvement. However, sometimes I feel like I'm missing out on something. How absolutely adorable would it have been to watch as Hermione and Viktor developed their little crush. (I KNOW! I'm suppose to feel what Harry does when he realizes what he's missed. I get it, shut it.)
As for the rest of the story, well you can tell that something had definitely changed. Like JKR got the go ahead for all 7 books and there was an excitement in her that breathed a sigh of relief that she'd be able to tell the tale that she'd envisioned.
BUT regardless of anything, Harry is not the best wizard. He's plucky, he's determined, he's got loads of street smarts. But of anything, he's lucky. I realize that there is an unspoken acknowledgement of this, but I really do wish that this would have been resolved. That Harry would have either learned to do his homework or he would have done something about what he brings to the group. And I think that it bothered me most in this book that he didn't recognize that, and it continued to bother me that he constantly whined about it for 3 more books.
One last thing about Goblet of Fire. You cannot talk about this book without thinking about the rest of the books. Book 1,2, and 3 stood alone as their own stories. Of course it was clear they were tales in the grand scheme of things, but still pretty isolated. 4,5,6 and 7 are 4 parts of one story.
Film IV
I'm not gonna lie. This is my least favorite of all the movies - by far. Right off the bat it gets on my nerves. The Quidditch World Cup scenes should have at least been 15% of the movie. Instead, it's like 5 minutes.
Then we have a whole wizarding world where people look JUST ever so slightly "different" than the muggle world, or in fact, look like they just stepped out of the Target Catalog/website. Everyone was styled entirely too "in fashion". I remember watching the movie for the first time in the theater and saying "what the shit" are they wearing? Not impressed, and nor would I be as this continued to be the trend for the next 4 movies. It makes sense for Hermione and Harry to dress this way, but Ron? Draco Malfoy? Funny enough, making the kids sport those ridiculous shag haircuts is going to date this movie far worse then the old timey production style of SS and CoS.
That being said, I have to say that the one change from the book I appreciated in the film was changing the source of the Gillyweed. As I've said before, I'm not a fan of Dobby. I'd forgotten from the first time I read the book to seeing the movie that Dobby was the one who procured the magical weed so Harry would be able to breath underwater. So when I read the book again and came across that plot point I actually thought I was reading something incorrect. I believe that it has more to do with Neville's character taking a more front and center position in the rest of the books then just the depiction of the movie that made me feel this way. Throughout all the books Neville as a character grows and becomes an increasingly more important character. I believe that to make this happen in the films the writer had to force Neville into situation he "shouldn't" be in. From the moment he stood up to the Golden Trio in SS, his role has been to reflect society as a whole. I think that it is through him we can see that the way we treat people does have a hand in how they behave.
Neville is Snape. They are different boys, yes. But their position in the class is exactly the same. They are the ones who have that specific otherness to them that kids do not know what to do with. So he is treated harshly to either conjole him into the same expected behavior or to be punish for it. Snape hates him because he sees his reflection. Where Snape was tortured by his peers, Neville is more or less left alone. Except in a few instances where his otherness is central to the success of his peers. But not because JKR plucked his name out of a hat and determined that he should save the day but because the character of Neville has something nobody else does. Otherness, the ability to see a situation from a certain point of view that all the rest cannot because they share exactly the same view.
Also, one has to surrender the possibility of the movie version being nothing more then a whisper of what happens in the book. If one watches just the movies, they will remain blissfully ignorant of the larger story. They will have the plot, the point, and some of the essential details. But they will not have the rich story that is the Tale of the Boy Who Lived.
Book IV - Goblet of Fire
I recently read a interview piece with JK Rowling. She admitted that there were times when she wished she could go back and make some edits to her books. I believe that she was specifically talking about book 4. But book 5 and 6 and some of 7 could be applicable. But I can see why it might have been so difficult to do when the later books in the series were first written. The publisher wanted books, I believe the movies were on their way and well, there was a lot of material that needed to be covered so that the entire story played out.
With any other writer, having to read over 800 pages of their words would be daunting and be way more then any reader needed to read. With JKR, it's not the case. She writes so well, and includes so much specific detail relevant to the greater story that you rarely feel that tugging feeling of boredom. She may have needed to edit, but she sure as heck didn't waste a word on the page.
However, I feel that she could have adjusted a lot of what she did write. Cutting something here, adding more there. I think it's important that she included times of reflection. And Harry does a lot of inner discussion to really give you a sense of what he's thinking and feeling. It's repetitive. Which, given the age and attitude of Harry is very consistant. But wouldn't have those words been best served by talking more about how the 3 schools interacted with each other? Yes? But then again, maybe that is not this book?
I am a reader torn between two minds.
First and foremost I would have liked to have had more going on with the students of Hogwarts, Beauxbatons, and Durmstrang. Even when I read book 4 the first time I felt that these students came all this way, to spend a whole school year in Scotland, and all they had was THREE challenges and a dance? Well that seems like a utter and complete waste of time.
One of the very well honed skills of JKR is to write from Harry's perspective and stay there. Anything that happens, is described solely through Harry's involvement. However, sometimes I feel like I'm missing out on something. How absolutely adorable would it have been to watch as Hermione and Viktor developed their little crush. (I KNOW! I'm suppose to feel what Harry does when he realizes what he's missed. I get it, shut it.)
As for the rest of the story, well you can tell that something had definitely changed. Like JKR got the go ahead for all 7 books and there was an excitement in her that breathed a sigh of relief that she'd be able to tell the tale that she'd envisioned.
BUT regardless of anything, Harry is not the best wizard. He's plucky, he's determined, he's got loads of street smarts. But of anything, he's lucky. I realize that there is an unspoken acknowledgement of this, but I really do wish that this would have been resolved. That Harry would have either learned to do his homework or he would have done something about what he brings to the group. And I think that it bothered me most in this book that he didn't recognize that, and it continued to bother me that he constantly whined about it for 3 more books.
One last thing about Goblet of Fire. You cannot talk about this book without thinking about the rest of the books. Book 1,2, and 3 stood alone as their own stories. Of course it was clear they were tales in the grand scheme of things, but still pretty isolated. 4,5,6 and 7 are 4 parts of one story.
Film IV
I'm not gonna lie. This is my least favorite of all the movies - by far. Right off the bat it gets on my nerves. The Quidditch World Cup scenes should have at least been 15% of the movie. Instead, it's like 5 minutes.
Then we have a whole wizarding world where people look JUST ever so slightly "different" than the muggle world, or in fact, look like they just stepped out of the Target Catalog/website. Everyone was styled entirely too "in fashion". I remember watching the movie for the first time in the theater and saying "what the shit" are they wearing? Not impressed, and nor would I be as this continued to be the trend for the next 4 movies. It makes sense for Hermione and Harry to dress this way, but Ron? Draco Malfoy? Funny enough, making the kids sport those ridiculous shag haircuts is going to date this movie far worse then the old timey production style of SS and CoS.
That being said, I have to say that the one change from the book I appreciated in the film was changing the source of the Gillyweed. As I've said before, I'm not a fan of Dobby. I'd forgotten from the first time I read the book to seeing the movie that Dobby was the one who procured the magical weed so Harry would be able to breath underwater. So when I read the book again and came across that plot point I actually thought I was reading something incorrect. I believe that it has more to do with Neville's character taking a more front and center position in the rest of the books then just the depiction of the movie that made me feel this way. Throughout all the books Neville as a character grows and becomes an increasingly more important character. I believe that to make this happen in the films the writer had to force Neville into situation he "shouldn't" be in. From the moment he stood up to the Golden Trio in SS, his role has been to reflect society as a whole. I think that it is through him we can see that the way we treat people does have a hand in how they behave.
Neville is Snape. They are different boys, yes. But their position in the class is exactly the same. They are the ones who have that specific otherness to them that kids do not know what to do with. So he is treated harshly to either conjole him into the same expected behavior or to be punish for it. Snape hates him because he sees his reflection. Where Snape was tortured by his peers, Neville is more or less left alone. Except in a few instances where his otherness is central to the success of his peers. But not because JKR plucked his name out of a hat and determined that he should save the day but because the character of Neville has something nobody else does. Otherness, the ability to see a situation from a certain point of view that all the rest cannot because they share exactly the same view.
Also, one has to surrender the possibility of the movie version being nothing more then a whisper of what happens in the book. If one watches just the movies, they will remain blissfully ignorant of the larger story. They will have the plot, the point, and some of the essential details. But they will not have the rich story that is the Tale of the Boy Who Lived.
Thursday, September 6, 2012
you're gonna suffer... but you're gonna be happy about it...
The thing I love most about this story, Hermoine starts to show her predilection to all things ginger - it is no coincidence that she chooses Crookshanks as a pet and he is the color he is.
Book III - Prisoner of Azkaban
I've read this book before. I've seen the movie numerous times. And yet, by the end chapters I was still sitting on the edge of my seat waiting for the information to unfold. You can only take my word for it when I tell you, I do not normally just forget important plot points of books or movies. So when I suddenly can't remember such specific and poignant story information it is a sign of a well written book. It shows that the writer has created such a detailed subplot and peppered the pages with rich character development that I am too distracted to concentrate on what I already know.
Now, unfortunately, there were a few different things that further distracted me. With the introduction of Aunt Marge, it got me thinking about what should have been Harry's extended family. Petunia mentions that her and Lily's parents were so proud to have a wizard in the family and they were excited to attended Lily and James' wedding. So what happened to them between the wedding, Harry's birth and then his parents death? And what about the Potter side? We know that Harry has no other family, so what happened to them? Now, I don't think the lack of this information is any huge flaw. In fact it's probably handled perfectly to just not delve into those facts beyond what the author did. But to a detailed reader, they are missed; even though I successfully convinced myself that Voldemort just killed them in his first bid for absolute power.
What I really liked about this book was that it presented a person to Harry that really genuinely cared about him as just a person: Professor Lupin. Remus did understand that due to circumstances beyond his control, Harry was special, but regardless of being the boy who lived he was really just a wizard. This of course was because Remus had the same experience. Through out all the books, there is the very CLEAR theme "You are not alone" but through Remus and his friends becoming animangous, it is the first applicable example shown to Harry of this fact. It is one thing to tell Harry that it is okay to rely on his friends, it is a completely different thing to show that it actually happens. This theme will repeat in variations through out the books, but it so very true and very important.
Film III
I think I under scored the previous movie. I should have said the comparison was about 75%. Because this one was definitely 60%. However, I didn't mind the lack of book material so much. Oh, it was glaringly obvious that stuff was missing, but because the director filled the movie with atmosphere I felt pacified. In the first two, I felt like I was just watching the things I'd imagined play out in front of me. But this third movie, I felt like I was somehow closer to the action, enveloped by it. Not so much like I'd fallen into the Pensive but more then just sitting in the living room staring at the television. According to IMDB, the director had suggested adding several things he'd thought up himself, but JK nixed them because they were not part of her vision (which is her prerogative) so he concentrated on what did exist and really made the film dynamic. A very smart move on his part.
The beginning was not satisfactory to me in any way. If I hadn't already known that I was suppose to cautious of the big black dog Harry briefly gets a passing glance of, then I surely would not have felt that from the scene in the movie. And I know I felt exactly that when I saw the movie the first time.
The whole Knight Bus sequence was visually interesting but utterly pointless (which is something I actually despise). It didn't start the way it was suppose to, didn't impart any information like it was suppose to and I pretty much kept thinking if they'd cut out all the fluff of it, we might have been able to see Harry enjoying his 2 weeks in Diagon Ally. In fact my annoyance about the whole sequence distracted me because it was so very different from what it should have been.
The thing is, when you read the books you get the ebb and flow of how Harry is able to cope his way through life. How he can be who he is. Life with the Dursley's is horrid, life at Hogwarts is deadly. So why is this kid ever hopeful, and not utterly depressed? Because sometimes, in between the torture and possible death, he gets a chance to really know pure, simple joy. The best example of this is when he eats and studies everyday at the Ice Cream Parlor. A moment that only exists in the book, and is completely obliterated in the movie.
I would definitely like to know more about the whole story regarding the decision to transfer directorial reigns from Christopher Columbus to Alfonso CuarĂ³n. It couldn't have been a simple one and they had to have known the enormity of impact the change of style would create. The look of the movies are completely different, the feel of the movies is at opposite ends of the emotional spectrum and the energy has entirely shifted. Yet it works! My theory is that it is because of where the kids are in their growth stage. For the most part the Trio and all the other students change very little between SS and CofS. They get a little taller, fill out a little bit, but they are essentially still little kids. But by PofA, they are in that puberty preparation stage. That moment where whatever is inside is tapping at the shell, bud, or cocoon. They are not little kids, but they haven't grown into teenagers either.
Something very specific happens in this movie that doesn't happen in the book and I really feel that it was a clever and important change that follows through to the end of the series - especially in the books. It is the kind of thing that makes you wonder if the author might regret the decision of having the scene play out the way it did.
Snape follows the trio down under the Whomping Willow because he wants to catch them in the midst of their shenanigans hoping to finally have the opportunity to dish out the comeuppance they so richly deserve. To see justice done when it always alluded him and those who taunted him.
But when he sees them in mortal danger, he becomes fiercely protective. In the Shrieking Shack you get the glimpse of a man torn in two, struggling to make two sides of himself co-exist. He stands facing those who tormented him, while trying to protect the only thing he has left of the one he always loved. Snape's tortured hateful side struggles with his protecting loving side and is unable to hear the pleas to listen to the truth. But we see later which side will always win. When Remus transforms, Snape does not hesitate to use himself as a shield to stand and protect the Trio.
This one action plants seeds for the revelations about who Professor Severus Snape really is. I think that this insight can only come after having made the entire 7 year journey through pages, film, and learned all you can learn about the inspiration and back story of Snape. Having all of that knowledge allows you to see in this movie the foreshadowing of what is the most poignant turn of the whole story, that Severus is the most tragic of all the characters.
Had he been the truly selfish and hateful side, he would have fled the scene, ridding himself of them forever. But it isn't until he is at the end of his life do you realize that because of who he is to Voldemort and to Dumbledore, because of his love for Lily, these two halves would never be at peace. But one is always stronger. He has to make Harry, Ron, and Hermoine's lives as difficult as he possible can, but he must give his life if their survival is threatened.
For me, it has always made me angry that James, Sirius, and Remus chose Peter as a friend over Severus. That they should have looked past the House, the difference, and saw what an ally they could have had in him. I know it's not how the story was written, and even if it was reality, it's just not that simple.
Tuesday, August 21, 2012
Weasley's wand causes devastation with the simplest spells.
The most brilliant pieces of writing in probably all 7 books are the bits regarding the growing Mandrakes.
Book II - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
I was not looking forward to reading the second book again. I remembered a lot more from this book then the first one. Mostly because I did not enjoy the whole flying car thing, and I enjoyed Dobby even less. For me, Dobby is the Jar Jar Binks of Harry Potter. And I am a big supporter of Jar Jar, but every moment that Dobby is wrecking havoc in Harry's life, I am cringing in frustration. I know they are characters that serve a greater purpose then just that dictated by the plot of the story. However, my annoyance by Dobby has more to do with feeling sympathetic for Harry in having to deal with this crazy magical basket-case then anything to do with how he was written.
I remember that before I read this for the first time, I had felt a bit of apprehension regarding how JK Rowling was going to follow her first book with an original story that would fit into the same plot with out it being essentially a copycat. I was impressed with the story she told.
As for the book as a whole, well that is a darn clever story. There is information seeping from every page. Developing character for Harry, little by litte. Little bit more background on Hagrid. Absolutely genius way to introduce some history of Voldemort with out having a current character explain the whole thing. The character of Tom Riddle is a very smart way of introducing just what is relevant to this book instead of having to divulge over much and wasting opportunity for the second book. Well done.
I don't like Dobby anymore now then I did then. Although I did consider starting one of those "End of the movie, slow clap for the underdog" moments when Dobby hauls off and zaps Mr. Malfoy after he's got his freedom. If anyone deserved it, it's that house elf.
One little detail I had a hard time coming to terms with: Hagrid's age. So, when the Chamber was last opened, Hagrid was in his 3rd year, and used as a scapegoat by Tom Riddle. 50 years later, he's the games keeper. This makes Hagrid at LEAST 63 years old. Or better, that by the time the students reach their 7th year he's 70? Yeah, no.
Film II - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
I'm gonna need to talk to the screenwriter about some of his choices. And if they weren't his, then I'll need to speak to whoever decided to make some really concerning "changes". Again, I'm not talking about having a known character present dialog that belongs to an entirely different book character (whom we will never meet). It's acceptable to have Prof. McGonagall relate the myth of the Chamber of Secrets instead of Prof. Binns. That works. What I'm talking about is changing the password to Prof. Dumbledore's from "Lemon Drop" to "Sherbert Lemon". I consider the fist a logical choice for making the most of what little screen time there is and the second to be an all out mistake done by people who should know better that takes away from the representation of the source material. It doesn't add, but it certainly takes away.
I felt this way through the whole movie. Chamber feels rushed and it makes the movie sloppy. I don't think the actors were given enough time to really get in touch with the material and therefore some of the scenes do not come across well. While I watched it, I was disappointed that several key parts of the book were missing. I eventually found them, in the deleted scenes. After watching them I felt that they ended up on the editing room floor due to essential problems with the pacing, writing, and stiff acting due more to direction then the fault of the actors.
Two particular scenes stand out as being complete let downs. The scene where Hermione is revealed to have drank the cat hair infused polyjuice potion should have been the crowning jewel moment for the whole movie. Yes, the basilisk is great, and what an awesome snake, but a human-cat? That should have been juiced for all it was worth. But it turned out to be a "don't blink or you'll miss it" scene. The second one that missed the mark was Tom Riddle speaking with Dumbledore. Not because of Tom, but because of Dumbledore. Here was a great opportunity to show us the progression of Hogwarts greatest Headmaster. And in 50 years and the man had not changed even a smidge. Here was a perfect moment to give him some depth, and it was entirely wasted.
60% comparison. Not satisfied at all.
PS. Kenneth Branagh was absolutely destined to play Gilderoy Lockhart (Even more so then the first person cast Huge Grant).
Book II - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
I was not looking forward to reading the second book again. I remembered a lot more from this book then the first one. Mostly because I did not enjoy the whole flying car thing, and I enjoyed Dobby even less. For me, Dobby is the Jar Jar Binks of Harry Potter. And I am a big supporter of Jar Jar, but every moment that Dobby is wrecking havoc in Harry's life, I am cringing in frustration. I know they are characters that serve a greater purpose then just that dictated by the plot of the story. However, my annoyance by Dobby has more to do with feeling sympathetic for Harry in having to deal with this crazy magical basket-case then anything to do with how he was written.
I remember that before I read this for the first time, I had felt a bit of apprehension regarding how JK Rowling was going to follow her first book with an original story that would fit into the same plot with out it being essentially a copycat. I was impressed with the story she told.
As for the book as a whole, well that is a darn clever story. There is information seeping from every page. Developing character for Harry, little by litte. Little bit more background on Hagrid. Absolutely genius way to introduce some history of Voldemort with out having a current character explain the whole thing. The character of Tom Riddle is a very smart way of introducing just what is relevant to this book instead of having to divulge over much and wasting opportunity for the second book. Well done.
I don't like Dobby anymore now then I did then. Although I did consider starting one of those "End of the movie, slow clap for the underdog" moments when Dobby hauls off and zaps Mr. Malfoy after he's got his freedom. If anyone deserved it, it's that house elf.
One little detail I had a hard time coming to terms with: Hagrid's age. So, when the Chamber was last opened, Hagrid was in his 3rd year, and used as a scapegoat by Tom Riddle. 50 years later, he's the games keeper. This makes Hagrid at LEAST 63 years old. Or better, that by the time the students reach their 7th year he's 70? Yeah, no.
Film II - Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
I'm gonna need to talk to the screenwriter about some of his choices. And if they weren't his, then I'll need to speak to whoever decided to make some really concerning "changes". Again, I'm not talking about having a known character present dialog that belongs to an entirely different book character (whom we will never meet). It's acceptable to have Prof. McGonagall relate the myth of the Chamber of Secrets instead of Prof. Binns. That works. What I'm talking about is changing the password to Prof. Dumbledore's from "Lemon Drop" to "Sherbert Lemon". I consider the fist a logical choice for making the most of what little screen time there is and the second to be an all out mistake done by people who should know better that takes away from the representation of the source material. It doesn't add, but it certainly takes away.
I felt this way through the whole movie. Chamber feels rushed and it makes the movie sloppy. I don't think the actors were given enough time to really get in touch with the material and therefore some of the scenes do not come across well. While I watched it, I was disappointed that several key parts of the book were missing. I eventually found them, in the deleted scenes. After watching them I felt that they ended up on the editing room floor due to essential problems with the pacing, writing, and stiff acting due more to direction then the fault of the actors.
Two particular scenes stand out as being complete let downs. The scene where Hermione is revealed to have drank the cat hair infused polyjuice potion should have been the crowning jewel moment for the whole movie. Yes, the basilisk is great, and what an awesome snake, but a human-cat? That should have been juiced for all it was worth. But it turned out to be a "don't blink or you'll miss it" scene. The second one that missed the mark was Tom Riddle speaking with Dumbledore. Not because of Tom, but because of Dumbledore. Here was a great opportunity to show us the progression of Hogwarts greatest Headmaster. And in 50 years and the man had not changed even a smidge. Here was a perfect moment to give him some depth, and it was entirely wasted.
60% comparison. Not satisfied at all.
PS. Kenneth Branagh was absolutely destined to play Gilderoy Lockhart (Even more so then the first person cast Huge Grant).
Friday, August 17, 2012
What aaaan idiot!
The text of that quote does not do justice to the line as seen in the movie.
As a summer distraction project, I decided that I should re-read all the Harry Potter books, and watch the movies. I was going to read all the books first and then watch the movies, but after I finished the first book, I just HAD to follow it with the movie.
Lets discuss.
Book 1 - Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
It has been more then likely 10ish years since I read this book. I probably blew through it faster then one should when reading an intelligently written and completely engaging story. I've read it exactly once before. As I read it this time I really tried to pace myself so I could really savor what I was reading.
What I really like about Harry Potter is that he is an eleven year old boy and the writer treats him exactly like that. There are some liberties that JK Rowlings takes with the character (most of the stuff that happened to Harry pre-Hogwarts would have left him seriously emotionally damaged) but he really is your typical eleven year old boy. It is also clear that even thought she is creating her very own world of places, characters and events, the author is writing "what she knows".
It surprised me how much of the content I didn't remember from the first time through. But it was nice, because I did feel like I was reading the book pretty much for the first time. Which does not happen often for me.
Oh, and I totally got a kick at how "teeny" the first book physically is.
Film 1 - Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone.
Boom! Wow, film production has dramatically changed in the last eleven years! (okay, that's really weird that I chose to do this experiment at 11 years.) And I'm not just talking about the difference in style of the various directors, but how the f/x were done, the camera shooting, and the building of the movie. Really thinking about it, I think I was less shocked about how much the actors had grown, versus how much the approach to film f/x has changed.
As for the actual translation of the story and plot to the big screen, I thought the same thing I thought then. I was a very solid movie, well crafted from the written word and included as much as it possible could in the constraint of 2 and half hours. However, it wasn't enough time to cover completely. Events, exposition, and characters got consolidated, to move the pace, a little disappointing, but no real jarring changes. I appreciat that JK was vehement they leave most of the material intact, and keeping the directors vision at a minimum.
I'd say about a 90% comparison. Very satisfied with both.
As a summer distraction project, I decided that I should re-read all the Harry Potter books, and watch the movies. I was going to read all the books first and then watch the movies, but after I finished the first book, I just HAD to follow it with the movie.
Lets discuss.
Book 1 - Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
It has been more then likely 10ish years since I read this book. I probably blew through it faster then one should when reading an intelligently written and completely engaging story. I've read it exactly once before. As I read it this time I really tried to pace myself so I could really savor what I was reading.
What I really like about Harry Potter is that he is an eleven year old boy and the writer treats him exactly like that. There are some liberties that JK Rowlings takes with the character (most of the stuff that happened to Harry pre-Hogwarts would have left him seriously emotionally damaged) but he really is your typical eleven year old boy. It is also clear that even thought she is creating her very own world of places, characters and events, the author is writing "what she knows".
It surprised me how much of the content I didn't remember from the first time through. But it was nice, because I did feel like I was reading the book pretty much for the first time. Which does not happen often for me.
Oh, and I totally got a kick at how "teeny" the first book physically is.
Film 1 - Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone.
Boom! Wow, film production has dramatically changed in the last eleven years! (okay, that's really weird that I chose to do this experiment at 11 years.) And I'm not just talking about the difference in style of the various directors, but how the f/x were done, the camera shooting, and the building of the movie. Really thinking about it, I think I was less shocked about how much the actors had grown, versus how much the approach to film f/x has changed.
As for the actual translation of the story and plot to the big screen, I thought the same thing I thought then. I was a very solid movie, well crafted from the written word and included as much as it possible could in the constraint of 2 and half hours. However, it wasn't enough time to cover completely. Events, exposition, and characters got consolidated, to move the pace, a little disappointing, but no real jarring changes. I appreciat that JK was vehement they leave most of the material intact, and keeping the directors vision at a minimum.
I'd say about a 90% comparison. Very satisfied with both.
Tuesday, November 16, 2010
It can only do good, dear, to bring joy and happiness.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


