All the News that's Fit to Share

Thursday, September 6, 2012

you're gonna suffer... but you're gonna be happy about it...


The thing I love most about this story, Hermoine starts to show her predilection to all things ginger - it is no coincidence that she chooses Crookshanks as a pet and he is the color he is.

Book III - Prisoner of Azkaban

I've read this book before.  I've seen the movie numerous times. And yet, by the end chapters I was still sitting on the edge of my seat waiting for the information to unfold.  You can only take my word for it when I tell you, I do not normally just forget important plot points of books or movies.  So when I suddenly can't remember such specific and poignant story information it is a sign of a well written book.  It shows that the writer has created such a detailed subplot and peppered the pages with rich character development that I am too distracted to concentrate on what I already know.

Now, unfortunately, there were a few different things that further distracted me. With the introduction of Aunt Marge, it got me thinking about what should have been Harry's extended family.  Petunia mentions that her and Lily's parents were so proud to have a wizard in the family and they were excited to attended Lily and James' wedding.  So what happened to them between the wedding, Harry's birth and then his parents death?  And what about the Potter side?  We know that Harry has no other family, so what happened to them? Now, I don't think the lack of this information is any huge flaw.  In fact it's probably handled perfectly to just not delve into those facts beyond what the author did.  But to a detailed reader, they are missed; even though I successfully convinced myself that Voldemort just killed them in his first bid for absolute power.

What I really liked about this book was that it presented a person to Harry that really genuinely cared about him as just a person: Professor Lupin.  Remus did understand that due to circumstances beyond his control, Harry was special, but regardless of being the boy who lived he was really just a wizard.  This of course was because Remus had the same experience.  Through out all the books, there is the very CLEAR theme "You are not alone" but through Remus and his friends becoming animangous, it is the first applicable example shown to Harry of this fact.  It is one thing to tell Harry that it is okay to rely on his friends, it is a completely different thing to show that it actually happens.  This theme will repeat in variations through out the books, but it so very true and very important.


Film III

I think I under scored the previous movie.  I should have said the comparison was about 75%.  Because this one was definitely 60%.  However, I didn't mind the lack of book material so much.  Oh, it was glaringly obvious that stuff was missing, but because the director filled the movie with atmosphere I felt pacified.  In the first two, I felt like I was just watching the things I'd imagined play out in front of me.  But this third movie, I felt like I was somehow closer to the action, enveloped by it.  Not so much like I'd fallen into the Pensive but more then just sitting in the living room staring at the television.  According to IMDB, the director had suggested adding several things he'd thought up himself, but JK nixed them because they were not part of her vision (which is her prerogative) so he concentrated on what did exist and really made the film dynamic.  A very smart move on his part.

The beginning was not satisfactory to me in any way.  If I hadn't already known that I was suppose to cautious of the big black dog Harry briefly gets a passing glance of, then I surely would not have felt that from the scene in the movie. And I know I felt exactly that when I saw the movie the first time.

The whole Knight Bus sequence was visually interesting but utterly pointless (which is something I actually despise).  It didn't start the way it was suppose to, didn't impart any information like it was suppose to and I pretty much kept thinking if they'd cut out all the fluff of it, we might have been able to see Harry enjoying his 2 weeks in Diagon Ally.  In fact my annoyance about the whole sequence distracted me because it was so very different from what it should have been.

The thing is, when you read the books you get the ebb and flow of how Harry is able to cope his way through life.  How he can be who he is.  Life with the Dursley's is horrid, life at Hogwarts is deadly.  So why is this kid ever hopeful, and not utterly depressed?  Because sometimes, in between the torture and possible death, he gets a chance to really know pure, simple joy.  The best example of this is when he eats and studies everyday at the Ice Cream Parlor.  A moment that only exists in the book, and is completely obliterated in the movie.

I would definitely like to know more about the whole story regarding the decision to transfer directorial reigns from Christopher Columbus to Alfonso CuarĂ³n.  It couldn't have been a simple one and they had to have known the enormity of impact the change of style would create.  The look of the movies are completely different, the feel of the movies is at opposite ends of the emotional spectrum and the energy has entirely shifted.  Yet it works!  My theory is that it is because of where the kids are in their growth stage.  For the most part the Trio and all the other students change very little between SS and CofS.  They get a little taller, fill out a little bit, but they are essentially still little kids.  But by PofA, they are in that puberty preparation stage.  That moment where whatever is inside is tapping at the shell, bud, or cocoon.  They are not little kids, but they haven't grown into teenagers either.

Something very specific happens in this movie that doesn't happen in the book and I really feel that it was a clever and important change that follows through to the end of the series - especially in the books.  It is the kind of thing that makes you wonder if the author might regret the decision of having the scene play out the way it did.

Snape follows the trio down under the Whomping Willow because he wants to catch them in the midst of their shenanigans hoping to finally have the opportunity to dish out the comeuppance they so richly deserve.  To see justice done when it always alluded him and those who taunted him.

But when he sees them in mortal danger, he becomes fiercely protective.  In the Shrieking Shack you get the glimpse of a man torn in two, struggling to make two sides of himself co-exist. He stands facing those who tormented him, while trying to protect the only thing he has left of the one he always loved.  Snape's tortured hateful side struggles with his protecting loving side and is unable to hear the pleas to listen to the truth.  But we see later which side will always win.  When Remus transforms, Snape does not hesitate to use himself as a shield to stand and protect the Trio.

This one action plants seeds for the revelations about who Professor Severus Snape really is. I think that this insight can only come after having made the entire 7 year journey through pages, film, and learned all you can learn about the inspiration and back story of Snape. Having all of that knowledge allows you to see in this movie the foreshadowing of what is the most poignant turn of the whole story, that Severus is the most tragic of all the characters.

Had he been the truly selfish and hateful side, he would have fled the scene, ridding himself of them forever.  But it isn't until he is at the end of his life do you realize that because of who he is to Voldemort and to Dumbledore, because of his love for Lily, these two halves would never be at peace.  But one is always stronger. He has to make Harry, Ron, and Hermoine's lives as difficult as he possible can, but he must give his life if their survival is threatened.

For me, it has always made me angry that James, Sirius, and Remus chose Peter as a friend over Severus.  That they should have looked past the House, the difference, and saw what an ally they could have had in him.  I know it's not how the story was written, and even if it was reality, it's just not that simple.







Also, if you ever get the chance check out the trivia on IMDB. It may not always be accurate but it's definitely interesting.

No comments:

Post a Comment